Values for Proof and Mint Sets

Using different price guides, I built a chart to compare the value of  Proof and Mint Sets as listed by different sources.
Numis = Numismedia Fair Market Value
USACB = USACoinBook
RB15 = 2015 Red Book
Prices are for straight run clad sets.

Proof and Mint sets are a commodity item: stable values, steady demand, highly consistent, widely available.  Yet, the values given by different sources can vary dramatically. How the data is gathered, how much data is included, and the algorithm used to calculate these values is dependent on the entity producing these price lists.

	Proof Set			Mint Set
	Numis	USACB	RB15	Numis	USACB	RB15
1968	8.2	8.47	8	6	7.31	7
1969	8	8.47	10	6	7.31	7
1970	13	10	10	19	19	18
1971	4	6.16	6	4	4.19	12
1972	5	6.16	6	4	4.19	7
1973	10	9.3	9	15	12	8
1974	13	12	11	6	7.31	8
1975	13	10	10	9	8.47	8
1976	10	9.3	9	9	8.47	8
1977	8	9.3	9	8	8.47	8
1978	6	8.47	8	6	8.47	8
1979	9	8.47	8	6	6.16	6
1980	5	7.31	7	8	7.31	7
1981	6	7.31	7	11	12	11
1982	6	5.29	5
1983	5	5.29	5
1984	6	6.16	6	5	4.19	4
1985	5	6.16	6	5	5.29	5
1986	5	6.16	6	9	9.3	9
1987	5	5.29	5	5	6.16	6
1988	5	7.31		5	6.16	6
1989	4	7.31	7	4	4.19	4
1990	6	7.31	7	5	9.3	5
1991	5	7.31	7	5	6.16	6
1992	4	6.16	6	5	6.16	6
1993	6	7.31	7	5	7.31	7
1994	6	7.31	7	5	5.29	5
1995	11	15	14	5	6.16	6
1996	9	9.3	9	18	22	21
1997	9	12	12	5	8.47	8
1998	13	12	11	5	5.29	5
1999	9	13	13	9	9.3	9
2000	8	8.47	8	10	10	10
2001	13	19	18	9	12	12
2002	9	13	13	9	12	12
2003	8	12	12	10	12	11
2004	13	12	12	11	12	12
2005	8	8.47	8	10	10	10
2006	10	16	12	13	13	13
2007	19	87	15	23	29	28
2008	31	36	85	38	68	65
2009	26	77	35	31	32	30
2010	35	77	75	28	29	28
2011	33	99	75	26	36	35
2012	38	36	95	63	68	65
2013	35	36	18	29	36	35
2014	35	36		31	36
2015	40	36		35	36